I decided to take a look at the
product “NatuRelief for Women,” which focuses on providing natural
relief for menstrual pain. First of all, on its packaging, NatuRelief says it
consists of a Bromelain dietary supplement with herbs, and it brandishes a “badge”
that says it contains natural pineapple enzymes. Because it does not specify
the actual workings of Bromelain, I decided to look it up myself on WebMD and
found the following:
Bromelain is an enzyme found in pineapple juice and in the
pineapple stem. People use it for medicine.
Bromelain is used for reducing swelling (inflammation),
especially of the nose and sinuses, after surgery or injury. It is also used
for hay fever, treating a bowel condition that includes swelling and ulcers
(ulcerative colitis), removing dead and damaged tissue after a burn
(debridement), preventing the collection of water in the lung (pulmonary
edema), relaxing muscles, stimulating muscle contractions, slowing clotting,
improving the absorption of antibiotics, preventing cancer, shortening labor,
and helping the body get rid of fat.
It is also used for preventing muscle soreness after intense
exercise. This use has been studied, and the evidence suggests bromelain
doesn’t work for this.
Some people use a product (Phlogenzym) for arthritis
(osteoarthritis) that combines bromelain with trypsin (a protein) and rutin (a
substance found in buckwheat). Bromelain used in this way seems to reduce pain
and improve knee function in people with arthritis.
There isn’t enough scientific evidence to determine whether
or not bromelain is effective for any of its other uses.
·
Bromelain seems to cause
the body to produce substances that fight pain and swelling (inflammation).
·
Bromelain also contains
chemicals that interfere with the growth of tumor cells and slow blood
clotting.
After looking into what Bromelain
does or is, at least, purported to do, I continued examining the packaging.
NatuRelief claims that its chewable tablets are “not habit forming” and are “drug
free,” which makes it appear more approachable to people who are into more
homeopathic approaches to stifling pain and symptoms and also to those who
might fear using more addictive substances in other kinds of drugs on the
market used to resolve menstrual pains. Because it comes in a chewable tablet
form, NatuRelief claims that it can provide “fast, on-the-go relief”…presumably
for those who don’t have the copious amounts of time to find a cup of water and
swallow a tablet. Then, NatuRelief claims that is the “The Natural Approach to
Coping with Menstrual Pain”…but not without an asterisk, which is elucidated at
the bottom of the package stating: “This statement has not been evaluated by
the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose,
treat, cure, or prevent any disease.” So there is not proof that this product
even works, at least, one might say, being that the FDA has not even evaluated
this product to check if what it claims is accurate. In addition to these
statements, at the front of its packaging, NatuRelief features a picture of a
tablet with a raspberry next to it, as though to say that what you’d really be
consuming is all natural substances just in tablet form. In addition, its
packaging has the color pink (to signify that it is for women) as well as the
color green (to add to the idea that the product is “natural”).
Now onto
the back of its packaging… there is a quote by the founder and president of
Concept in Health, Inc.—the distributor of NatuRelief. What hits me the most
from what she says is: “I would feel comfortable giving to my family
[NatuRelief] […] Long used by many native cultures, Bromelain works safely.” Of
course, this statement on the back is also accompanied by an asterisk
referencing the same as before about the FDA not having evaluated such claims.
Again, though, we see how NatuRelief continues to push how safe and natural it
is, how there is a long history in its usage. It almost seems as though we are
lucky to have acquired the “secret” of native cultures in helping soothe bodily
pains.
As a side
note, I looked into the Concepts in Health, Inc., and I actually was not able
to find much information about them online. I saw that they had a “Company
Overview” page about them on Bloomberg. However, it said that they manufacture and
deliver dietary supplements for menopause symptoms for adults—there was
no mention of menstrual pain symptoms. Also, there were no recorded key
executives on said page.
Furthermore,
in terms of the ingredients listed at the back of the packaging, it says that
in one tablet of NatuRelief, there is 400mg of Bromelain along with a 25mg “Proprietary
Blend” of Dandelion Root, Ginger Root, and Red Raspberry Leaf—the daily value
is not established. Other ingredients include xylitol, stearic acid, magnesium
stereate, natural flavors, and silica.
Its directions
state to take one tablet as a dietary supplement and to take another serving if
desired. Its warnings state that the product is only for adult use. Do not use
within two weeks of surgery or if allergic to pineapple. It also says to
consult one’s health provider if on an anti-coagulant, antibiotic, or any other
medication, or if suffering from a bleeding disorder or liver damage. Lastly,
its price is $4.59.
Something
that I find interesting about this product is its lack of advertising, which
almost adds to its trustworthiness and credibility… it adds to its “small
company” image that goes against the grind. It makes a statement through this
lack of presence as its distinguishes itself from all the capitalistic, revenue-driven
heavy advertising conducted by, what one can rightfully think, the untrustworthy
and lying corporations that only want profit rather than to help their
customers and that forego consideration of the health of their customers only
to push unpronounceable drugs to them that seem to have more side effects than
productive and desirable effects. This made me think about the way in which this
“failure” in situating itself in the foreground might benefit NatuRelief’s
sales. “I’ve never heard of it, so it must be good!” might constitute a kind of
counterintuitive way of thinking that could at least work for those stereotypical
“woke” (but not too woke), organic-only, health-conscious hipsters.
Hi Shereen,
ReplyDeleteI think you picked a very good example for this blog. I’ve been reading in a lot of similar examples to your findings of studies conducted on the effectiveness of drugs. “There isn’t enough evidence that this drug is effective.” I think that suggests that companies will try to market anything that they can as being beneficial when there is little evidence to prove that. I thought your observation of this drug was very interesting and agree it’s kind of crazy that products that are marketed as natural are perceived as healthier and better when those labels clearly don’t necessarily mean anything. I think it is good that there are statements on labels that say things like, “This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease,” and whether or not it has been evaluated by the FDA. However, it is also important to remember that a majority of people looking for any kind of pain relief are not necessarily looking at this. Would more effective drug labeling regulations would help people know what they are really buying? I think analyzing the packaging of different drugs can be very eye opening and makes me feel like I should do extensive research before buying drugs from the store.
Often thought that if you just add 'for women' to any product, you can sell it.
ReplyDelete